Jurors consider assault charges against Minneapolis cop |

Jurors consider assault charges against Minneapolis cop

  • Article by: PAUL LEVY , Star Tribune
  • Updated: April 13, 2013 – 12:06 AM

A Minneapolis SWAT team leader says he punched a fellow bar patron in self-defense.

Jurors will continue deliberating Saturday whether Minneapolis SWAT team leader Sgt. David Clifford, a highly trained officer once lauded by the United Nations for his professionalism, is guilty of assaulting a fellow patron in an Andover bar.

Closing arguments in the felony case that could send Clifford to prison for seven years concluded Friday afternoon and the Anoka County jury reviewed evidence for several hours before adjourning shortly for the night after 10 p.m.

Clifford, 48, contends he was acting in self-defense when he punched Brian Vander Lee, 44, at Tanners Station in Andover on June 16.

The incident was captured on a dark and sometimes grainy surveillance video. Clifford testified in Anoka County District Court that he approached Vander Lee, who was sitting at the next table, and told him to curb his loud and abusive language. He and his attorney, Fred Bruno, claimed throughout the two-week trial that Vander Lee, who was very drunk, then stood up, cocked his left arm and attempted to throw a punch. Clifford, who was off-duty, reacted with a right and Vander Lee fell backward and cracked his head against the outdoor patio floor. He had two immediate brain surgeries and a third within weeks of the incident.

“The camera doesn’t lie,” Bruno told jurors during closing arguments, referring to the surveillance video and blown-up still photos that the jury saw repeatedly throughout the trial.

But prosecutors noted that Clifford never said a thing about Vander Lee throwing a left at him when he initially turned himself in to the county sheriff, on June 17, nearly 19 hours after the incident at Tanners. It was only after Clifford had conferred with Bruno and watched the video with his lawyer that he spoke of a Vander Lee punch, said prosecutor Blair Buccicone.

“Brian Vander Lee is not a threat,” Buccicone said to a packed courtroom.

Buccicone replayed the video and pointed out that not a single Tanners Station patron seemed disturbed by the loud and off-color language being used by brothers Brian and Mike Vander Lee.

“Here’s the thing,” Buccicone told the jury. “There was bad language being used. But that does not merit a punch to the face.”

Both sides noted that Clifford is a highly trained officer in sound physical condition. Bruno said Clifford reacted instinctively when he saw Vander Lee cock his left arm. Vander Lee’s blood-alcohol level was 0.189 percent, more than twice the legal limit for driving.

“You put Brian Vander Lee sober in a ring against David Clifford, that is not even a fair fight,” Buccicone told the jury. But drunk? “That’s a blowout,” he said.

Vander Lee, who testified earlier this week, said he could not remember much of the incident. Buccicone said that Vander Lee has experienced headaches and that his hearing, eyesight, and senses of smell and taste “will never be the same.”

Prosecutors also highlighted Clifford’s actions following the punch. He fled the scene and later called members of the Minneapolis Police Federation, seeking legal counsel. He never called 911 and didn’t answer his door when sheriff’s deputies came to his house after midnight. Clifford testified he left the scene to protect others, avoiding a melee.

Buccicone asked why Clifford didn’t just walk away in the first place, instead of throwing a punch.

“He’s not trained to do that,” the prosecutor said. “He’s trained to win.”

Paul Levy • 612-673-44

via Jurors consider assault charges against Minneapolis cop |

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s